RSS
 
 

HP Servers with Non HP Disk Drives, Where is Temperature Sensor #29 on DL380?

05 Nov

I have a home built system consisting of several HP Proliant DL380 Gen7 & Gen8 servers.
Now normally when sitting idle these are solid servers with fairly low power consumption and in many cases Whisper quiet when under no load.

That was until a recent upgrade of a failed disk drive.
Actually the server went from one seagate drive to almost exactly the SAME model of Seagate drive with a slight difference in the part number.

From a ST2000LM007 to ST2000LM015, both are: 2.5″ SATA 6Gb/s 5400RPM, 128Mb ram.
This simple change has left the internal fans running at 90% of full speed and continual warnings of the drives over heating.

Temperature Sensor #29
It is believed that this is a “pseudo sensor”, take a bunch of system temperatures pass them though a formula or table matrix and arrive at some sort of “system Health” number.
Why think this?, because it is possible to “fool” this sensor in reporting different temperatures that are not related to anything temperature like in particular

There has also been a very interesting support note released by HP recently covering most of the HP production and EOL systems.
Notice/ ProLiant Gen7 Gen8 and Gen9 Servers – Fan Speed May Be Higher Than Expected If No Hard Drive Is Present In the System

I think what we are looking at is not actually a system problem ,but rather a iLO X problem, or more likely a design “feature” to lock down the hardware.
Why would anyone run a server without disk drives?, simple…. cloud implementation… throw in a few optical connectors to an optical switch and a fiber based NAS
and you have very cheap computing systems that can be easily configured from a central location ,no local disk drives needed.

Problem is, that this increase in fan speed “by design” as HP likes to put it , is potentially breaking the law of some countries related to Environmental impact of electronic equipment.
Those extra ramped up fans are adding 90-100W to the power consumption , which equates to over 2KWh a day. which adds up to several hundred KWh per year of power that is being “deliberately wasted” for no reason what so ever(parts NOT fitted in the server, as an option to SAVE power resources.).

 

Leave a Reply

 

*